Mimecast vs Barracuda Email Security -- Enterprise Email Gateway Compared

Mimecast vs Barracuda Email Security

Barracuda Email Security and Mimecast are both enterprise email gateway solutions. Barracuda Email Security email threat protection platform available as gateway appliance or cloud service, while Mimecast cloud email security platform with threat protection, archiving, and continuity. The best choice depends on your organization's size, technical requirements, and budget.

Last updated

The Verdict

Choose Barracuda Email Security if significantly lower pricing than Proofpoint and Mimecast is your priority and small-to-mid-market organizations wanting effective email security at a lower price point than Proofpoint or Mimecast. Choose Mimecast if email continuity keeps mail flowing during outages — unique differentiator matters most and mid-to-large enterprises wanting a unified email security, archiving, and continuity platform with strong API integrations.

Used Mimecast or Barracuda Email Security? Share your experience.

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

FeatureBarracuda Email SecurityMimecast
PricingCustom pricing / per-user licensingFrom $3.60/user/month / appliance pricing varies
Pricing ModelPer-user subscriptionPer-user subscription or appliance license
Open SourceNoNo
DeploymentCloudCloud, Self-Hosted
Best ForMid-to-large enterprises wanting a unified email security, archiving, and continuity platform with strong API integrationsSmall-to-mid-market organizations wanting effective email security at a lower price point than Proofpoint or Mimecast
Multi-layer email threat scanningNot availableSupported
Link and attachment sandboxingNot availableSupported
Anti-spam and anti-malware filteringNot availableSupported

When to Choose Each Tool

Choose Barracuda Email Security when:

  • +You value email continuity keeps mail flowing during outages — unique differentiator
  • +You value strong impersonation and brand protection capabilities
  • +You value unified platform covering security, archiving, and continuity
  • +You want to avoid detection efficacy below Proofpoint for advanced targeted threats
  • +You want to avoid cloud-native API protection less mature than gateway product

Choose Mimecast when:

  • +You value significantly lower pricing than Proofpoint and Mimecast
  • +You value available as both appliance and cloud service for deployment flexibility
  • +You value straightforward administration with less complexity
  • +You want to avoid detection efficacy slightly behind Proofpoint for advanced threats
  • +You want to avoid email archiving search performance can be slow on large datasets

Pros & Cons Comparison

Barracuda Email Security

Pros

  • +Significantly lower pricing than Proofpoint and Mimecast
  • +Available as both appliance and cloud service for deployment flexibility
  • +Straightforward administration with less complexity
  • +Good value for small-to-mid-market organizations
  • +Includes awareness training (PhishLine) at no additional cost

Cons

  • Detection efficacy below Proofpoint for advanced targeted threats
  • Cloud-native API protection less mature than gateway product
  • Reporting and analytics less sophisticated than enterprise competitors
  • Threat intelligence depth does not match Proofpoint or Mimecast
  • Support quality inconsistent compared to premium vendors

Mimecast

Pros

  • +Email continuity keeps mail flowing during outages — unique differentiator
  • +Strong impersonation and brand protection capabilities
  • +Unified platform covering security, archiving, and continuity
  • +Good API ecosystem for SIEM and SOAR integrations
  • +Easier administration compared to Proofpoint for mid-market teams

Cons

  • Detection efficacy slightly behind Proofpoint for advanced threats
  • Email archiving search performance can be slow on large datasets
  • Pricing is still premium and comparable to Proofpoint
  • URL rewriting can break some legitimate links
  • Security awareness training less mature than dedicated platforms

Sources & References

  1. Barracuda Email Security — Official Website & Documentation[Vendor]
  2. Mimecast — Official Website & Documentation[Vendor]
  3. Barracuda Email Security Reviews on G2[User Reviews]
  4. Mimecast Reviews on G2[User Reviews]
  5. Barracuda Email Security Reviews on TrustRadius[User Reviews]
  6. Mimecast Reviews on TrustRadius[User Reviews]
  7. Barracuda Email Security Reviews on PeerSpot[User Reviews]
  8. Mimecast Reviews on PeerSpot[User Reviews]
  9. Gartner Magic Quadrant for Email Security 2024[Analyst Report]
  10. Forrester Wave: Enterprise Email Security, Q2 2024[Analyst Report]
  11. SE Labs: Email Security Gateway Tests[Independent Testing]
  12. Anti-Phishing Working Group: Phishing Activity Trends[Industry Research]
  13. Gartner Peer Insights: Email Security[Peer Reviews]

Mimecast vs Barracuda Email Security FAQ

Common questions about choosing between Mimecast and Barracuda Email Security.

What is the main difference between Mimecast and Barracuda Email Security?

Barracuda Email Security and Mimecast are both enterprise email gateway solutions. Barracuda Email Security email threat protection platform available as gateway appliance or cloud service, while Mimecast cloud email security platform with threat protection, archiving, and continuity. The best choice depends on your organization's size, technical requirements, and budget.

Is Barracuda Email Security better than Mimecast?

Choose Barracuda Email Security if significantly lower pricing than Proofpoint and Mimecast is your priority and small-to-mid-market organizations wanting effective email security at a lower price point than Proofpoint or Mimecast. Choose Mimecast if email continuity keeps mail flowing during outages — unique differentiator matters most and mid-to-large enterprises wanting a unified email security, archiving, and continuity platform with strong API integrations.

How much does Barracuda Email Security cost compared to Mimecast?

Barracuda Email Security pricing: From $3.60/user/month / appliance pricing varies. Mimecast pricing: Custom pricing / per-user licensing. Barracuda Email Security's pricing model is per-user subscription or appliance license, while Mimecast uses per-user subscription pricing.

Can I migrate from Mimecast to Barracuda Email Security?

Yes, you can migrate from Mimecast to Barracuda Email Security. The migration process depends on your specific setup and the features you use. Both platforms offer APIs that can facilitate automated migration. Consider running both tools in parallel during the transition to ensure zero downtime.